×
Father Forces One Daughter To Kill Other Daughter's Boyfriend And Then Marries The Other Daughter
ADVERTISEMENT

Father Forces One Daughter To Kill Other Daughter's Boyfriend And Then Marries The Other Daughter

"look at my other options. I didn't feel that I had a choice," the woman said at her plea hearing.

Screencapture / 59News / Youtube
ADVERTISEMENT

Editor’s note: This article was originally published on February 1, 2021. It has since been updated.

Anna Marie Choudhary’s story is a horrendous one of deceit and murder. It all started when Choudhary's sister, Amanda McClure, and her boyfriend John Thomas McGuire, 38, moved in with Choudhary and their father, Larry McClure Sr; as reported by People. During their stay, Choudhary recalls having noticed her father often "go off to the side" to speak to her sister but says that she wasn't yet aware of an intimate relationship between the two.

ADVERTISEMENT

On the night of the murder, the family was preparing for a meal together. What John Thomas Mcguire didn’t see coming is that after a meal of steaks, potatoes, and a bottle of wine, he was going to be tortured and murdered.

John Thomas McGuire / Screencapture / Truecrime - Youtube / BlueField Daily Telegraph

Choudhary recalls her father asking her to cut up some pieces of rope a few hours before the incident, a request that didn't seem strange to her at the time. She recollected that her sister Amanda had kept the wine bottle close at hand that night. Larry and Amanda then managed to fool the other two into playing a game with them, one that would involve tying the person up and requiring them to escape. “When Larry said he wanted to play a game, a trust game, Amanda had been joking about how she was able to get out of anything," said Choudhary. "She was able to tie herself up and nobody will believe she could tie herself up that way,” she further added.